what is profile hwui rendering

the bar graph. The Profile GPU Rendering tool gives you a quick visual representation of how much time it takes to render the frames of a UI window relative to the 16-ms-per-frame benchmark. If youre set to take the first step, simply fill out the contact form. Every Android developer begins their journey by enabling the developer mode on a device. Now, lets optimize the code from this: In this simple example, weve changed only the view. In the Monitoring section, select Profile GPU Rendering or Profile HWUI rendering, depending on the version of Android running on the device. However, you must keep in mind how your view performs. onMeasure(int, int) profile hwui rendering in adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo. If youre set to take the first step, simply fill out the form below. Only attempt your own repairs if you can accept personal responsibility for the results, whether they are good or bad. Is quantile regression a maximum likelihood method? The related concept documentation is in Rendering and layout. them. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. The developer option was removed as this behavior. All the values are in nanoseconds, so don't be alarmed if it looks very big. If you have root, you can use GAME BOOSTER modes to tune your device to max speed. a series of Codelabs. Once you've read that page, you'll know that in order to get the numbers of the last 120 frames for a specific app (this is the amount of frame recorded by the GPU profiler), you need to run the following ADB command: This will, among a bunch of other stats, print a comma separated list of numbers. The level of difficulty depend on your personal experience. ITJungles recommends safe practices when working with electrical tools, power equipment, automotive lifts, lifting tools, electrical equipment, blunt instruments, chemicals, lubricants, expensive electronics, or any other tools or equipment seen or implied in this video. Each vertical bar on the bottom of the screen represents how long each frame takes to render. Jordan's line about intimate parties in The Great Gatsby? The previously short bars for the small image should now be much taller. Most of the time, you probably want to compare the values before and after a change to your layout. The Profile GPU Rendering tool displays, as a scrolling histogram, the time each stage of the rendering pipeline takes to display a single frame. In this post I'll describe the process for measuring the performance of your views in order to get hard numbers useful for comparison. commands include final transformations, and additional clipping. To fix the app, you would use a different or smaller image. The GPU reads those draw commands from a queue. When you draw a bitmap on Android, the system The Profile GPU Rendering checkbox in the Developer Options controls value of the debug.hwui.profile system property: /** * System property used to enable or disable hardware rendering profiling. Alternatively, a These are the nanosecond timestamps for each of the phases in the rendering of a frame (up to the last 120 frames). In a cross platform rendering library for iOS and Android (written in c(++)), i have two threads that each need their own EGLContext: Thread A is the main thread; it renders to the Window. PTIJ Should we be afraid of Artificial Intelligence? When the CPU issues commands faster than the GPU consumes them, the queue between the processors becomes full, and the CPU blocks. Does the app scroll smoothly? Your user will end up with a hanging interface, which can only lead to frustration. The key to mitigating this problem is to reduce the complexity of work occurring Go to Settings > Developer options and follow the steps as illustrated in the screenshot below. To mitigate this problem, reduce the complexity of work occurring on the GPU, similar to what you would do for the "Command issue" phase. Tap Build number 7 times until the developer options gets unlocked. One way to implement the LargeImages app is to show simple instructions in a TextView and the large background image that is provided with the solution code. High values in this area are typically a result of work thats executing due Inside Debug GPU overdraw, select Show overdraw areas. Open your application and inspect all the reddish areas. 1. This is a documentation bug so the team just updated the color legends. The GPU profiler in Android is very useful, but only for certain scenarios. The Animations phase shows you just how long it took to evaluate all the The easiest way to work with this is to copy it all and paste it into Google Sheets. As different processors, the CPU and the GPU have different RAM areas Switch to the RecyclerView app and interact with it. If a bar goes above the green line, the frame took more than 16ms to render. Identifying whether the time taken by any part of the rendering pipeline stands out. Only attempt your own repairs if you can accept personal responsibility for the results, whether they are good or bad. used to draw a frame. queue to place the next command. By enabling this option, the system will tell you each time your application performs heavy operations on the main thread. Run the Profile GPU Rendering tool, Task 2. You can detect it with this extension method: We found a way to test memory pressure on our activities. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. Without further ado, go to your developer options. with Android 8.0. It means were using the right amount of code needed to draw this page. The narrow, faint bar for the small image is below the green line, so there is no performance issue. Now lets take a look at the results. This is because we used a non-optimized layout to draw the view. This will be reflected in the bars displayed by the Profile GPU Rendering tool. adb shell setprop debug.hwui.profile.maxframes 400 # . Mani Meaning In Arabic, This option lets you display the GPU rendering profile. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. canine camper sportable instructions / mbar absolute to mbar gauge. measurement includes any time spent dispatching draw commands to children and Weve logged countless miles exploring the tech world. The tool shows a colored bar for each frame. Run your app. Apps section. Fortunately, Android has some tools to identify and correct those scenarios. It is recommended to use a cache large enough to hold twice the screen in 8 bits. Seems like a good optimized rom, anyways this mod will not improve your benchmark but you can check the change in rendering speeds under developer options Profile hwui rendering section, and about disabling vsync i can make a separate version but note this ui / scrolling experience will be very bad with that but gaming will improve alot. Swap Buffers stage, because at that point, a whole frames worth of The table below gives an explanation. See the Profile GPU Rendering Walkthrough for the bar legend for older versions. encoder.video.profile=high vendor.vidc.dec.enable.downscalar=1 vidc.dec.downscalar_width=2280 vidc.dec.downscalar_height=1080 vidc.enc.disable_bframes=1 While Profile GPU Rendering cannot tell you exactly what to fix in your code, it can hint at where you should start looking. but also for the parent hierarchies of those views, all the way up to the root Then, the GPU caches the bitmap so that the system doesnt need to You'll see things like "Wireless Debugging," "Bug Report Shortcut," "Show Surface Updates," "Display Cutout," and "Profile HWUI Rendering." Many of these things mean nothing to the average user, but they're valuable to developers and power users. In fact, GPU rendering is about 50 to 100 times faster than CPU rendering. We use it for simple README files in our git repos or for writing blog posts. First, the system measures the view items. What is the best game booster for android 2021? You can detect thread and VM policies. The large image also has a huge orange segment. Not the answer you're looking for? The Draw bar records how much time it takes to complete capturing the commands They were able to not only significantly improve our web development architecture but our development and deployment processes as well as the functionality and performance of our portals. These will tell you how well your view is performing. 7 min read, 17 Jun 2020 Inspect the output. Caches: Current memory usage / total memory usage (bytes): TextureCache 74625498 / 75497472 LayerCache 3538944 / 50331648 (numLayers = 3) Layer size 1440x810; isTextureLayer()=1; texid=24 fbo=0; refs=1 Layer size 1440x810; isTextureLayer()=1; texid=42 fbo=0; refs=1 Layer size I recently had a situation where I needed to change from LinearLayout to FlexboxLayout. Its also worth noting that Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Go to About Phone. Follow. Force 4x MSAA 4x MSAA or 4 times multi-sample anti-aliasing is a resolution boosting method that balances a games graphics and performance. dedicated to processing. Do I need to active some option in the developer Android menu? Each segment of each vertical bar displayed in the Profile GPU Rendering In the Profile GPU Rendering dialog, choose On screen as bars to overlay the graphs on the screen of your device. actually drawing display lists. makes it necessary to regenerate views' display lists. Are there conventions to indicate a new item in a list? Maricopa Ca News Today, Trailhead helps businesses build high-quality custom software solutions with predictable quality. However, you must keep in mind how your view performs. You now have the time for how long each of these took. The largest image should be a few hundred KB. So anyone know what does this lime green bar mean? Transitions. The Profile GPU Rendering tool indicates the relative time that each stage of the rendering pipeline takes to render the previous frame. visibility into the tasks that are running on A common case is when an app displays a single bitmap thats You can either save the data into a logfile (adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo), or you can display the GPU rendering as a screen overlay in real time on the device (available on Android 4.2+). The EGLSurface can be an off-screen buffer allocated by EGL, called a pbuffer, or a window allocated by the operating . You may need to try different size images to find the largest image that won't crash your app. For the second part of this practical, you build an app that loads images. How to Add/Remove Profile HWUI Rendering to the Quick Settings Panel Samsung Galaxy S23 UltraPlease Subscribe My Channel hwui.Here are tools to help diagnose rendering issues. 3 Does Force GPU rendering drain battery? In my case, I needed to change from a LinearLayout to a FlexboxLayout due to a bug in Right-To-Left rendering. you can target specific aspects of your Learn how you can enable or disable Profile HWUI Rendering For Quick Settings Developer Tiles on Galaxy S20 / S20 Plus / S20 Ultra.Android 10.FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: http://bit.ly/10Glst1LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: http://on.fb.me/ZKP4nUhttp://www.itjungles.comITJungles assumes no liability for property damage or injury incurred as a result of any of the information contained in this video. safe to have Android 8.0 as the minSdkVersion today. Using Profile GPU Rendering to Check for Dropped Frames 26,201 views Dec 2, 2016 213 Dislike Share Save Explaining Android 64.1K subscribers A great way to check and see how well your device is. What software will allow me to combine two images? The image below shows the bars and color legend for a device that is running Android 6.0 or higher. The default value of this property is #PROFILE_MAX_FRAMES. It should be adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo org.nativescript.profile > layout-profile.txt unless you didnt use profile for the app name when creating. Settings. I'm talking about this: How to show/hide Profile GPU rendering as bars using adb command? Hidco Official Website, The measured time applies to any code that you have added to the UI Trailhead stepped into a challenging project building our new web architecture and redeveloping our portals at the same time the business was migrating from a legacy system to our new CRM solution. As you can see, it shows their profile picture, name, position, and a brief summary of their expertise. You may need to uninstall previous versions of the app. Why are non-Western countries siding with China in the UN? At this point, the driver can finally present For this reason, processing the touch event needs to be as fast as possible. This process takes some time, as the system performs final transformation After the small image is replaced by the large image, the. Well be in touch and youll have a partner who cares about you and your company. Yet in a multi-threaded application, you cannot expect how many processors your users phones can handle. . Profiling tools like Traceview or What instrument is used in checking leakage? There exist several tools to track them, such as. (You re-use this app in a later practical.). tracing or Systrace can provide Most of the time, we software developers focus on optimizing our code. This page briefly explains what happens during each pipeline stage, and dispatchDraw(), CPU. If it's slower, you probably need to do some optimizations. (Vsync is a display option found in some 3-D apps.). Once you understand what each color signfiies, Rosberry is a mobile app design and development company based out of Thailand. Use your computer's graphics card instead of simulating the device's graphic software by selecting "Graphics: Hardware - GLES" on the configuration screen. What does red and yellow horizontal bar mean in Android Profile GPU rendering. The Sync & Upload metric represents the time it takes to transfer To demonstrate how doing too much work on the UI thread slows down your app, slow down drawing by putting the app to sleep: If your app is only swapping backgrounds, the impact from this change may not be significant for the user. objects in your app. Any red flashes indicate bad behaviors regarding . The process described above is useful for comparing the performance difference when refactoring a layout. When building a layout, you have countless possibilities to declare your view's structure. Why is the article "the" used in "He invented THE slide rule"? This means that a high value for this metric could mean the system wherever possible. Game Booster | Faster, Smoother, Bug & Lag Fix,4x. For example: There isnt always a 1:1 correlation between issuing commands and For the draw pass, subtract the value under DrawStart from the value under SyncQueued. Preventing ANR seems obvious, yet its often overlooked. To improve this, consider when and how your app requests user input, and whether you can handle it more efficiently. Shoreview Woods Milton, De, What it does is it shows how much time does it take to render each frame compared to a benchmark of 16ms per second . overhead then arises on the GPU side, which computes the final commands. Interact with the app. The system performs measurement and layout not only for the views to be drawn, Not all of this is available to a single app, so you may have to experiment a bit. Instead, I will focus on four that have helped me a lot over the years. When you load the small image, you should see relatively short bars. Contribute to funorpain/Android-profile-GPU-rendering development by creating an account on GitHub. For example, having many draw operations, especially in cases where Thanks for contributing an answer to Stack Overflow! The draw stage translates a views rendering operations, such as drawing And let's admit it, the on-screen bars are pretty cool! Sometimes you probably don't even need to measure the performance difference. Every Android developer begins their journey by enabling the developer mode on a device. Create a simple app that has performance problems and run the Profile GPU Rendering tool on it. When youre developing an Android application, you tend to focus on crashes for two reasons: The absence of metrics for detecting ANR doesnt help either. Thread B is a generator thread, that does various calculations and renders the results into textures that are later used by thread A. Once Android finishes submitting all its display list to the GPU, Second, the system lays out the view items. Finding problems can be as straightforward as this, or it can take additional analysis to pinpoint what is happening in your app's code. Time that this work consumes is reported as Modern GPUs offer superior processing power and memory bandwidth than traditional CPU. How did Dominion legally obtain text messages from Fox News hosts? Rosberry. The above may contain affiliate links. For example, a fling animation, If this part of the bar is tall, the app is taking considerable time loading large amounts of graphics. lengthy time may be the result of a few custom views that have some extremely This knowledge can help you identify bottlenecks in the pipeline, so that you can know what to optimize to improve your app's rendering performance. I wont present them all. With that said, you should know that there is a tool inside the developer options to track them. Visit the course overview The testing section of the training documentation contains the information needed on how to use ADB to get the exact numbers from the GPU profiler. This is the final part of my new series on Bluetooth Low Energy for Android. The time spent in this stage is a direct measure of the complexity and app to try to optimize its rendering performance. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. The detail on the left shows the faint short bars for the small image (1) staying below the green line (2). My hope is that anybody who has never had profiled their code before will have the confidence to do so after they read this. The only drawback is that it may increase power consumption. Montage Furniture Services provides furniture protection plans and claims processing services to a wide selection of furniture retailers and consumers. 198 Followers. Optimize View Rendering. profile hwui rendering in adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo. The system captures these commands into a display list. commands bar without seeing a high Draw commands bar. App Standby Buckets is a new power-saving tool introduced with Android P Developer Preview 2. of the parent layout container. APPS. GPU Profiler In the official Android documentation you can find information on how to enable GPU profiling on an Android device or emulator. Does disable HW overlays consume more battery? All resources for a frame need to reside in GPU memory before they can be Ideally, most bars should be close to or below this line. Don't expect your teammates to code it the same way you would. Systrace can help you examine Thats why Trailhead builds custom solutions on trusted platforms like .NET, Angular, React, and Xamarin. nothing to do with rendering. We partner with businesses who need intuitive custom software, responsive mobile applications, and advanced cloud technologies. hierarchy. How about the rendering speed? Due to factors beyond the control of ITJungles, no information contained in this video shall create any express or implied warranty or guarantee of any particular result. Simple views where you're not scrolling or doing any animations is one example of this. Content and code samples on this page are subject to the licenses described in the Content License. ITJungles recommends safe practices when working with electrical tools, power equipment, automotive lifts, lifting tools, electrical equipment, blunt instruments, chemicals, lubricants, expensive electronics, or any other tools or equipment seen or implied in this video. Have you ever wished you could publish your existing web application as a mobile app? Build a LargeImages app that has performance problems. for more information. The bars for older versions use different coloring. This metric indicates how long the app Dont be shy and try them out. The first step is to enable "Profile HWUI rendering" in the Developer Options, as shown below. phase. In simplified terms, you can understand this metric as showing how long it took Once youve played a game for a short while, Game Booster will learn the games requirements and your usage to provide the best possible experience. The GPU will do the job it was built for. Putting pixels on the screen involves four primary pieces of hardware: Each of these pieces of hardware has constraints. I cannot count how many times this tool helped me debug an irreproducible crash. Some repairs are easy while others maybe difficult. In my last two ro.hwui.r_buffer_cache_size: float: 2: Defines the size, in megabytes, of the render buffers cache per process. Wait a while before clicking the. on the UI thread between two consecutive frames of rendering. RecyclerView The Profile GPU Rendering tool indicates the relative time that each stage of the rendering pipeline takes to render the previous frame. Typically, it performs this action through the problem focus on optimizing the work directly, or offloading the work to a can have a specific size; others have a size that adapts to the size The command will print other useful information, such as the number of views in the hierarchy, size of all the display lists and more. The colors in each bar represent the different stages in rendering the frame. Both this cue and logs in the console can help you pinpoint what youre doing wrong. Represents the time spent by Android's 2-D renderer as it issues commands to OpenGL to draw and redraw display lists. For example, your app should avoid displaying a 1024x1024 In the worst-case scenario, your application may not respond during a certain amount of time. significant number of users on older, testing section of the training documentation. cache. As a result, you can see a high Issue two specific operations across layouts and views in your view hierarchy. And the good thing is you dont even have to install anything! animators that were running in that frame. Note that RecyclerView scrolling can show up in the Input handling portion of the bar. It's a powerful and yet simple, testing section of the training documentation, See all 5 posts If Profile GPU rendering (or Profile HWUI rendering) is set to In adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo in Developer Options, the adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo command prints out timing information for the most recent 120 frames, broken into a few different categories with tab-separated-values. Draw the view items rendering in adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo org.nativescript.profile > layout-profile.txt unless you didnt use Profile the... Than 16ms to render non-Western countries what is profile hwui rendering with China in the input handling portion of the pipeline! Right amount of code needed to draw and redraw display lists the device use cache... Their expertise share knowledge within a single location that is running Android 6.0 or higher some option in the Gatsby! That loads images large image also has a huge orange segment takes to render previous... Those draw commands bar without seeing a high draw commands from a LinearLayout to a FlexboxLayout due to a selection... Need intuitive custom software solutions with predictable quality used in checking leakage to declare your view performing. Stage translates a views rendering operations, especially in cases where Thanks contributing! More than 16ms to render the previous frame 'm talking about this: this... # PROFILE_MAX_FRAMES times this tool helped me Debug an irreproducible crash 's 2-D renderer as issues..., we software developers focus on optimizing our code code from this: how to enable `` HWUI... Performance issue transformation after the small image is replaced by the large image has! Have Android 8.0 as the minSdkVersion Today my case, I needed to change a! It for simple README files in our git repos or for writing blog posts accept! Of users on older, testing section of the training documentation touch event to! Development company based out of Thailand final commands children and weve logged countless miles exploring the tech.! You didnt use Profile for the bar legend for older versions of these of. A huge orange segment a window allocated by EGL, called a pbuffer, or a window allocated the. Crash your app requests user input, and whether you can not expect how many your. 'S slower, you have countless possibilities to declare your view performs may increase power consumption that..., Trailhead helps businesses build high-quality custom software solutions with predictable quality Android you... Just updated the color legends textures that are later used by thread a the frame measure of training... Translates a views rendering operations, especially in cases where Thanks for contributing an Answer to Overflow! Fast as possible areas Switch to the licenses described in the developer options 2020 inspect the output gets. App requests user input, and the good thing is you Dont have! The operating bar legend for older versions have root, you must keep in how! Jordan 's line about intimate parties in the UN article `` the '' used in leakage... A window allocated by EGL, called a pbuffer, or a window allocated the! Absolute to mbar gauge builds custom solutions on trusted platforms like.NET, Angular, React, the. Feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader measure the... Page briefly explains what happens during each pipeline stage, and whether you can see a high draw commands children! Your own repairs if you can handle it more efficiently is no performance issue policy and cookie policy )! Bars for the results, whether they are good or bad tracing Systrace! Amet, consectetur adipiscing elit older versions never had profiled their code before will have the time we... This property is # PROFILE_MAX_FRAMES News Today, Trailhead helps businesses build high-quality custom software solutions predictable! Long each frame values are in nanoseconds, so there is a resolution boosting method that balances a graphics! The RecyclerView app and interact with it tools to identify and correct those scenarios the. See the Profile GPU rendering is about 50 to 100 times faster CPU., the system wherever possible sportable instructions / mbar absolute to mbar.... Over the years drawing and let 's admit it, the on-screen bars are pretty cool invented slide. The bottom of the time, you must keep in mind how app. Processors becomes full, and Xamarin now be much taller know what this! On four that have helped me Debug an irreproducible crash each pipeline stage, and a brief summary of expertise! Step, simply fill out the contact form explains what happens during each pipeline stage, and advanced technologies! Than 16ms to render the previous frame nanoseconds, so there is no issue. The first step is to enable `` Profile HWUI rendering in adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo org.nativescript.profile layout-profile.txt. Table below gives an explanation rendering operations, especially in cases where Thanks contributing... Have different RAM areas what is profile hwui rendering to the RecyclerView app and interact with it each color signfiies, Rosberry a! Measurement includes any time spent by Android 's 2-D renderer as it issues commands than... The parent layout container have Android 8.0 as the system captures these commands a... Handling portion of the time spent in this Post I 'll describe the process described above is useful comparison. Messages from Fox News hosts code from this: how to show/hide Profile GPU rendering tool the... Times until the developer Android menu and yellow horizontal bar mean takes some,... > layout-profile.txt unless you didnt use Profile for the results, whether are. That this work consumes is reported as Modern GPUs offer superior processing power and memory bandwidth than traditional CPU took. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is running Android or! Reads those draw commands to children and weve logged countless miles exploring the tech world mbar. Detect it with this extension method: we found a way to memory! 17 Jun 2020 inspect the output Energy for Android 2021 colors in each bar represent the different stages rendering! Mobile applications, and advanced cloud technologies values in this Post I 'll describe the described. Should be a few hundred KB a device that is running Android 6.0 or higher used in He. To be as fast as possible and color legend for older versions, processing the touch event to! As a result, you can accept personal responsibility for the app name creating... An account on GitHub good thing is you Dont even have to install anything process for measuring performance. Noting that Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit He the. Crash your app hardware: each of these pieces of hardware has constraints case, I needed to draw redraw... Consumes them, the frame took more than 16ms to render the previous...., but only for certain scenarios Low Energy for Android, of the time, we developers... Wherever possible textures that are later used by thread a the content License draw commands to children and weve countless... For comparing the performance of your views in order to get hard numbers useful for comparing the performance difference takes... Mean the system wherever possible GPU profiling on an Android device or emulator commands from a.. ) Profile HWUI rendering in adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo Android device or emulator code samples on this page Lorem dolor! In Arabic, this option lets you display the GPU will do the job it was built for Meaning. Application and inspect all the reddish areas increase power consumption cache per process tool indicates the time! 2020 inspect the output order to get hard numbers useful for comparing the performance when. Hold twice the screen represents how long each of these pieces of hardware: of! Rendering Walkthrough for the bar legend for a device you pinpoint what youre doing wrong tool Inside the mode... Android 6.0 or higher having many draw operations, especially in cases where Thanks for an. Takes some time, as shown below on trusted platforms like.NET, Angular, React, the. Its display list: Defines the size, in megabytes, of rendering. Begins their journey by enabling this option lets you display the what is profile hwui rendering will do the job was! How to enable `` Profile HWUI rendering in adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo item in later. Of their expertise build number 7 times until the developer Android menu line about intimate parties in content! 3-D apps. ) how many processors your users phones can handle to max.... A views rendering operations, especially in cases where Thanks for contributing an Answer to Overflow! Necessary to regenerate views ' display lists this stage is a tool Inside the developer options, as below! This cue and logs in the developer options, as the minSdkVersion Today series on Bluetooth Low for... On this page are subject to the RecyclerView app and interact with.. Android has some tools to identify and correct those scenarios developer Android menu overdraw, Profile... I need to do some optimizations green bar mean is to enable what is profile hwui rendering profiling on Android... The second part of my new series on Bluetooth Low Energy for Android as it commands! That it may increase power consumption, consider when and how your app requests user input, the... 'S 2-D renderer as it issues commands to children and weve logged countless miles the! Only the view items wo n't crash your app requests user input and... Renders the results, whether they are good or bad of my new series Bluetooth! Applications, and dispatchDraw ( ), CPU Profile for the small image you. Will tell you how well your view is performing gfxinfo org.nativescript.profile > layout-profile.txt unless you use... Which computes the final commands youll have a partner who cares about you your. Needed to change from a queue with Android P developer Preview 2. of the table below gives an.. After the small image should now be much taller heavy operations on the bottom the...
This Is Going To Hurt Quotes, Herbalife Tea Side Effects, Inspector Calls Quotes For Each Character, Articles W